Mendota Heights Legislators Remain Cool to Voter ID as Debate Heats Up

Proponents of voter ID laws are pushing for a constitutional amendment.

A proposed constitutional amendment to require voters to present photo identification drew nearly five hours of testimony last week in a Senate hearing.

Meanwhile, on the House side, District 39A Rep. Rick Hansen (D-South St. Paul) said he received 78 emails as of last Thursday night opposing the initiative.

“That makes opposition to that the number one thing I’ve heard from so far this year,” said Hansen.

If the Legislature passes the initiative, voters will decide in November whether to add a fourth criteria to determine voter eligibility into the constitution. Referendums bypass the veto pen of the executive branch.

Not having sat on the Local Government and Elections committee that heard testimony last Wednesday,  Sen. Jim Metzen (D-South St. Paul) said he needs to research voter ID, but said he’s more resolved against the idea of using the constitution to pursue the measure.

“”Philosophically, I don’t think we should go down the road of putting everything on the ballot as a constitutional amendment. I think we’re going to end up like California.  … I just don’t think it’s the right way to govern.”

Hansen voted against putting voter ID laws in statute last year, and said the constitution should be used to expand, not limit rights or enfranchisement.

“When there are problems with voting, it’s not because someone is impersonating someone else. That’s what requiring a voter ID would solve,” said Hansen.

He said the most common violation of election law occurs when felons who have not had their rights restored still turn out to the polls. “A photo ID would not do anything with that.”


The Legislature is taking a break Monday and Tuesday to allow for outstate legislators to return to their districts for party caucuses on Tuesday evening.  

Check out our for more information.

Sen. Jim Metzen


 Higher education private institutions disclosure requirements expansion. SF1647 awaits a hearing in the Higher Education Committee. introduced Feb. 2 

A list of all legislation authored by Sen. Jim Metzen this biennium is available on the Minnesota Legislature's website.

Rep. Rick Hansen

A list of all legislation authored by Rep. Rick Hansen this biennium is available on the Minnesota Legislature's website.

Pamela Ehrlich April 07, 2012 at 12:53 PM
I agree that we should not have a constitutional amendment to require a voter ID when voting. I strongly feel that before voting, the voting public should be made aware of all of the costs associated with requiring a voter ID such as extra training for election judges, new equipment and problems with the new system that will occur. The additional costs have not been made public. What are they? Also, for the relatively few fraud cases, is the expense worth it? Could the money necessary to implement voter ID be used elsewhere such as in our schools?


More »
Got a question? Something on your mind? Talk to your community, directly.
Note Article
Just a short thought to get the word out quickly about anything in your neighborhood.
Share something with your neighbors.What's on your mind?What's on your mind?Make an announcement, speak your mind, or sell somethingPost something
See more »