This past week, the anticipated Lilydale Regional Park Environmental Assessment Worksheet report was completed and submitted to Saint Paul Parks & Recreation by their contractor, Emmons & Olivier Resources, Inc (EOR). Friends of Lilydale Park received a copy of the report by mail Saturday, June 9. To date, we have not seen the report posted on the City's website, but presumably they will post this week.
We have begun to peruse the report and thought it important to share some of the things found in our initial scan. Our reaction was "Wow!?!" And not in a good way. We had expected the EAW to be an environmental analysis of Park staff's proposed new Lilydale Park roadway, buildings etc. and how those things fit with a "natural-resources based park." The report is that - and more. The report includes new elements Park staff have added to the plans for Lilydale Park - that to the best of our knowledge have not been presented or discussed by the LilydalePark Task Force or in any other public forum. Here are a few of the things from the report:
- A startling (never-heard-discussed-ever-before in our 13.5 yrs of being a Friends group) comment that "motorized use of the (Pickerel) lake is considered."
- Also, a map showing a second "future picnic shelter" of unspecified size located beside Pickerel in the new, now dubbed "central gathering area" of Lilydale Park; and
- Nearby, a new 10'-wide paved trail will replace the current, recently-constructed, rustic trail along the lake.
- The current unpaved small lot by the lake still disappears in place of a new 25-car paved lot to be placed alongside "Pickerel Clearing." The "clearing" is still planned to be built on the to-be-mounded-up site atop the continuing to decompose, gas-venting old town of Lilydale landfill.
- There is more of the report we need to read, but clearly Parks' staff has no shortage of ideas for how to "improve" Lilydale Park.
Last week, Saint Paul Parks & Rec announced via the Pioneer Press that the required public hearing on the report will be held Monday, June 18, 6:30 p.m. at Neighborhood House. The public will be limited to comments of three minutes and may speak only to the EAW report. Parks assured the West Side Citizen Organization (District Council) staff that even if people haven't had access to the EAW report to read or consider, EOR, the paid consultant, will provide an overview at the hearing. It was interesting for us to read in EOR's proposal to Parks to become the EAW vendor, that among their company's strong attributes: a long history of working with and understanding Parks' staff needs.
There will be a 30-day period for taking written public comments beginning Monday, June 11, although it is not clear in the report who to address comments to or where to send them.
As soon as we learn more, we will provide an update.
Grit Youngquist & Jon Kerr
1:19 am on Tuesday, June 12, 2012
The city website now has a link to the EAW http://www.stpaul.gov/index.aspx?nid=2693 Print copies available at Saint Paul Central Library, Saint Paul Riverview Library, and West Side Community Organization offices.
The website notes that in addition to next Mon, June 18, 6:30pm meeting at Neighborhood House, the EAW is available for written public comment from June 11, 2012 to July 11, 2012.
Written comments can be sent to: Alice Messer
City of Saint Paul Department of Parks and Recreation
400 City Hall Annex
25 West 4th Street
Saint Paul, MN 55102
or by email to:
alice.messer@ci.stpaul.mn.us.
We suggest you also cc your comments to the Minnesota Environmental Quality Board, Env.Review@state.mn.us
You may also want to let Mayor Chris Coleman know your thoughts & feelings: Chris.Coleman@ci.stpaul.mn.us - along w/ Saint Paul City Council members - or any other elected officials. All comments are welcome regardless of residence as Lilydale is a Regional Park using Met Council & State of Minnesota Legacy Funds for the proposed "improvements."
Danielle Cabot
4:11 pm on Wednesday, June 13, 2012
Thanks for all the info, guys. I'm interested in people's thoughts on possible motorized use of Pickerel Lake, since that seems to be the newest suggestion being circulated. Also, if anyone wants to provide further comments or counterpoint on the park's development, let me know if you would like help commenting, submitting a blog or a letter to the editor.
MikeL
9:16 am on Thursday, June 14, 2012
It's a small lake. I would prefer that they keep it non-motorized only.
Seth Hayden
7:46 pm on Thursday, June 14, 2012
Pickerel Lake's undeveloped nature is what makes it such a treasure for our area. I grew up in the middle of nowhere fishing and birding, and if it weren't for place like Lilydale Park and Crosby Farm, I'd have moved out of this area long ago. Not to mention the park's value as bird breeding habitat. The last round of improvements they made to the Pickerel parking/trail area were needed, are aesthetically appealing, and make the spot more accessible. Let's protect this rare peace of urban wilderness!